There are some really great bakeries online that deliver their gourmet caramel cakes to almost any doorstep.
- Most caramel cake choice, best delivery at Gold Belly | $69+
- Oprah’s favorite caramel cake @ Caroline’s Cakes | $65
- BIG caramel cakes at Savannah’s Candy Kitchen | $79.95 + Free Shipping
- Bourbon caramel cake at Sugar Avenue Bakery Co | $69.95 + Free Shipping
- Customize your caramel cake at Sweet E’s Bake Shop | $59
- Alternative options to caramel cake at Etsy | $40+
- Most affordable option at Pieces Of Cake | $35
You’ll see the top caramel cake choices available right now and what each bakery does that sets them apart from the rest.
These bakeries have spent years of tweaking their closely guarded caramel cake recipes, and it’s shown first hand by the quality and finesse they put into each and every cake.
Ready? Let’s check out the best bakeries online that deliver caramel cake to any doorstep….these are going to make your mouth water!
Goldbelly
#1 Gourmet Food Marketplace
Multiple Bakery Choices
Gold Belly connects small artisan bakeries nationwide with people just like you, looking for gourmet caramel cakes for delivery.
There’s a surprisingly wide selection of caramel cakes offered on it’s bakery marketplace and even some great alternatives to consider if you’re open to them.
Here are some of the best bakeries on Gold Belly that ship caramel cake nationwide.
Caroline’s Cakes 7-Layer Caramel Cake
One of Oprah’s favorite things and mentioned on her Oprah Magazine, Caroline’s Cakes have nearly perfected how to make a killer caramel cake. They’ve been doing it since 1982!
It’s literally layer upon layer of caramel bliss. The bakers take seven moist yellow cake layers and fill each one with Caroline’s signature rich melty caramel icing.
This isn’t a small cake by any means. It’ll serves 14-20 people and measures 9″ across.
If you’re thinking about gifting this cake, maybe for a birthday, anniversary or just because, it comes in a Caroline’s Cakes signature gift box.
BUY: Check out more information on Caroline’s Cakes and order one of their famous 7-layer caramel cakes on their Gold Belly page here.
Savannah’s Candy Kitchen Caramel Layer Cake
Savannah’s Candy kitchen have been making delicious treats for over 30 years.
Their signature Caramel Layer Cake features three huge layers of moist golden yellow cake. In between is rich caramel icing that they make from scratch in their copper kettles.
For locals, their brick and mortar store in Savannah, Georgia is a hot spot and is also frequently visited by tourists.
This cake isn’t a light weight, it serves 10-12 people and measures 8″ across.
BUY: Check out more information on Savannah’s Candy Kitchen and order your own Caramel Layer Cake on their Gold Belly page here.
Sugar Avenue Memphis Bourbon Caramel Cake
This is a special take on caramel cakes from Sugar Avenue.
They’ve partnered with Memphis distiller Old Dominick and their Huling Station Bourbon to create an infused cake overflowing with rich deep sweet caramel flavors.
Each of their cakes features small batch made hand crafted caramel, that’s made with love .
This cake servers 10-12 people and measures 8″ across. Included is one jar of caramel sauce that you need to pour over the cake right before you serve it.
If you’re gifting this, you can add a handwritten gift note for an extra personal touch.
BUY: Check out more information about Sugar Avenue and order your own Bourbon Caramel Cake on their Gold Belly page here.
River Street Sweets
Huge southern style caramel cakes
Southern Caramel Layer Cake
Not only do you get a drenching of caramel on the outside of this huge 12 person cake, but you’ll also find their caramel baked into the sponge too.
River Street Sweets say it’s their best tasting cake recipes they’ve ever created. I think you should be the judge of that?
BUY: Check out more information on River Street Sweets and order your own Southern Caramel Layer Cake here.
Sweet E’s Bake Shop
Most beautiful caramel cake
Salted Caramel Cake
A gorgeous looking salted caramel cake that’s the most customizable option on this list.
Sweet E’s Bake shop offers this salted caramel cake in six different configurations so you can make sure there’s enough cake for everyone at your event – and also not overspend by buying an oversized cake.
A super cool feature about Sweet E’s Bake Shop is that you can customize the cake flavor.
Not just simple vanilla, yellow or chocolate sponge – I’m talking Chocolate Raspberry Truffle, Rainbow Candy Spill and Red Velvet Cream Cheese.
There are even more customization options:
- Add a message banner on the cake with your custom message
- Add a cake box for an extra special first impression wow
- Add a gift note
- Add a cake topper – birthday, wedding, gender reveal, congrats…
- Add candles
- Add sparklers
- Add balloons and flowers
- Add extra treats like cookies, marshmallow squares or brownies
It’s a lot!
The frosting surrounding the moist sponge cake is rich salted vanilla caramel. You’ve got a crazy selection of awesome choices for the insides, so pick your favorite! You want to order an extra cake size up so people can go back for seconds?
BUY: Check out more information on Sweet E’s Bake shop and order your own Salted Caramel Cake on their website here.
Soulfully Yours Bakery
A dreamy mix of caramel and chocolate
Soulfully Yours Bakery makes an ultra premium caramel chocolate cake made from top quality ingredients.
It features seven layers of delight alternating between rich Belgian chocolate cake, creamy caramel custard and chocolate New York cheesecake.
Their caramel custard has a more velvety and creamier feel to it than the sugar frosting other bakeries feature on their caramel cakes. It balances the New York chocolate cheesecake with a little caramelly sweetness.
Each chocolate layer cake is hand decorated with dark Belgian chocolate buttercream and rich caramel glaze.
BUY: Check out more information about Soulfully Yours Bakery and order your own Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake on their website here.
Piece Of Cake
Most affordable caramel cake
This is the most affordable caramel cake on this list, featuring moist yellow cake layers with rich buttery caramel icing.
It’s an old fashioned style treat, who’s taste will be enjoyed by everyone.
They do offer a 9-inch cake, but the bakery requires you pick that up directly from them or delivered local. For nationwide shipping, they ship a 7-inch, 3-layer caramel cake.
BUY: Check out more information about Piece Of Cake and order your own Caramel Layer Cake on their website here.
Etsy
Small businesses with BIG flavors
Etsy might not be the first place you’d think about when you’re shopping for a caramel cake that can be shipped, but it’s worth a look.
Some of the best treats are made at the smallest bakeries that are often not given the spotlight as much as they deserve.
Check out this offering from Heidi’s Feel Good Foods.
It’s a salted caramel pecan cheesecake. A little different from the other caramel cakes so far, but it looked delicious and reviewers love it.
It’s a blend of nutty, sweet, gooey, creamy and salty deliciousness and for added bonus it’s ketogenic, vegan, non-GMO and gluten free.
BUY: Check out more information about Heidi’s Feel Good Foods on their Etsy page here.
Choose between an 8″ or 9″ diameter old fashioned caramel layer cake and indulge!
Reviewers love the presentation and cake tin the caramel cake arrives in, they also love everything from the sponge cake to the caramel frosting commenting that there’s a perfect balance so it’s not overly sweet or dry.
The bakers who make this cake still use the same technique that was perfected by their Southern grandmothers. They first caramelize sugar with a wooden spoon in a cast iron kettle. They cook it down, allow it to cool and smother their moist sponge cakes in it.
There’s a lot of ways not to make caramel – it’s awfully picky about maintaining the correct temperature when it’s being made and it’s not hard to burn it when it gets too hot.
This two layer cake measures 8″ or 9″ across and will serve 8-10 or 10-12 people. If you want to go big, opt for their 9″ three layer cake that’ll serve 14-16 people.
BUY: Check out more information about Gracious Plenty Foods on their Etsy shop page here.
Bake Me A Wish!
The best salted caramel chocolate cake
For the last caramel cake that can be shipped online, check out this Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake from Bake Me A Wish!
It features two moist layers of chocolate cake that are topped with a creamy blend of caramel frosting, drizzles of caramel sauce and a sprinkling of salt.
It’s all finished with cake crumbs and chocolate chips around the sides of the cake and packaged in a delightful bakery gift box.
It’s a really good choice for gifting to someone, it looks delicious too! For a special touch, Bake Me A Wish even includes a greeting card that you can personalize.
The cake measures 7 inches in diameter and serves between 6-8 people. Bake Me A Wish! ships this caramel cake nationwide in refrigerated packaging.
Don’t worry about having too much cake (is that a problem?!), put the leftovers in the freezer and it’ll stay good for up to 2 months.
If it lasts that long 🙂
BUY: Check out more information about Bake Me A Wish! and order your own Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake on their website here.
Roundup
You’ve got some great options when you’re shopping online for the best caramel cake that can be shipped online.
My first recommendation would be to check out the Gold Belly food marketplace. They’ve gathered together what could be the best caramel cakes in the country and offers to ship them freshly made to almost anywhere in the nation.
Not only do you have the choice of classic caramel cakes, you can also find treats like pumpkin caramel cakes, caramel pecan cakes, salted caramel swirl cheesecakes and even salted caramel pies.
Gold Belly is a good place to start.
For the most customizable caramel cake, you’ve got to check out Sweet E’s Bake Shop. You can really build your perfect caramel cake by custom selecting the sponge flavor, filling, cake size and shape, message banner, cake toppers, candles, sparklers and more. It’s quite impressive and you’ve got to check it out for yourself here.
The most premium top shelf OMG caramel cake goes to Soulfully Yours Bakery. It’s got seven layers of yum, alternating between Belgian chocolate cake, creamy caramel custard and rich velvety New York chocolate cheesecake.
Etsy has some good alternative options like salted caramel pecan cheesecakes and they’re a little more affordable than the more established bakeries.
For an affordable option, check out Pieces Of Cake and their Caramel Layer Cake. It’s $35 and features three layers of moist sponge cake filled with rich buttery caramel frosting.
Hopefully this guide has given you some good ideas on the best caramel cake that can be shipped nationwide. They’re all good, you just have to pick the one that fits your event or occasion the best.
