Italian cream cake or sometimes called Italian wedding cake, is a unique combination of moist vanilla sponge cake, coconut, pecans and creamy whipped frosting.
It can be quite a task to make on your own, so if you would feel better leaving the baking to the pros, there are several excellent bakeries who specialize in authentic Italian cream cake that can help.
- Best overall Italian cream cake delivered @ 3 Brothers Bakery | $44.99
- Expertly made Italian cream cake delivered @ Iron Chef Cat Cora on Gold Belly | $69
- Most WOW & Authentic Italian cream cake delivered @ Soulfully Yours Bakery | $99+
- Different Italian cream cake delivered @ Rustika Bakery | $79
- Best nutless alternative Italian cream cake @ Montilio’s | $79
Every bakery has a slightly different version of Italian cream cake, but they all offer delivery nationwide to almost any US doorstep.
See the best bakeries that deliver Italian cream cake in this epic roundup of the best of the best.
3 Brother’s Bakery
Best quality and value
One of 3 Brothers Bakery’s most popular items, their take on a classic Italian ice cream cake features three layers of Italian cream cake filled with rich cream cheese.
Lightly toasted pecans and coconut cover the outsides of the cake while the top is finished with cream cheese rosettes and pecan halves.
BUY: Check out more information about 3 Brothers Bakery and order your own Italian cream cake for delivery nationwide on their website here.
Chef Cat Cora
Iron Chef & Entrepreneur
Iron chef Cat Cora is offering you the chance to try her special Italian cream cake who’s recipe was passed down from her beloved Grandma.
This cake was so special that it was served at all types of events and celebrations, like anniversaries, weddings, funerals, baptisms and….of course birthdays.
Chef Cora remembers that her Grandma made, “a moist, silky cake, with a frosting so luscious and creamy that you couldn’t keep your fingers away from it no matter how hard you tried”.
You can try this cake and get it delivered to your door through gourmet marketplace Gold Belly. The Italian cream cake measures 6-inches across and serves 6-8 people. It’s heavy and dense, weighing in at 4.5lbs.
BUY: Check out more information about Chef Cat Cora and order your own Italian cream cake for delivery on her Gold Belly page here.
Soulfully Yours Bakery
Beautiful & Authentic Italian Cream Cakes
Soulfully Yours Bakery makes some really nice cakes.
They’re featured quite a bit on Treat Buyer and always offer high quality cakes. Their Italian cream cake isn’t any different.
Also known as an Italian wedding cake, this cake features super moist sponge cake with lightly toasted coconut and walnuts folded in.
The layers are sandwiched between sweetened cream cheese buttercream and the cake is finished with more toasted coconut and walnuts on the outside.
Soulfully Yours Bakery uses a century old recipe for their Italian cream cake – originally created by an Italian great-grandmother who owned patisseries in Italy.
You can choose between four sizes of this cake, depending on your celebration or event size:
- 5-inch (feed 8)
- 6-inch (feeds 10)
- 7-inch (feeds 12)
- 8-inch (feeds 14+)
This is a beautiful cake and would look the part on any dessert table to WOW your guests.
BUY: Check out more information about Soulfully Yours Bakery and order your own mail order Italian cream cake (or wedding cake) on their website here.
Rustika Cafe and Bakery
Caramel, Coconut and Walnuts
One of Houton’s best cake shops, Rustika Cafe and Bakery was founded in the mid 1990’s and has been family run ever since.
Their Italian caramel cream cake features three layers of moist vanilla caramel cake loaded with walnuts. They fill each one with their house made signature Italian buttercream.
To finish the cake, lightly toasted coconut decorates the edges with more buttercream and caramel drizzle on top.
This cake measures 6-inches across and will serve 6-8 people.
BUY: Check out more information about Rustika Cafe and Bakery and order your own Italian caramel cream cake for delivery on their Gold Belly page here.
Sugaree’s
Elegant and Simple
Sugaree’s has put it’s own Southern spin on Italian cream cake.
They’ve taken three layers of moist coconut, pecan and walnut butter cake and layered each one with fresh juicy pineapple, cream cheese icing and pecan sprinkles.
It’s a unique combination that’s made daily from scratch in their small-batch kitchen.
Sugaree’s originally started out as a small home-based business, but expanded to a retail shop just four years later.
Southern style and old fashion baking methods are at the heart of Sugaree’s.
BUY: Check out more information about Sugaree’s and order your own Italian Cream Cake for delivery nationwide on their Gold Belly page here.
Montilio’s Baking Company
Delicious, moist and creamy
Montilio’s Baking Company offers this extra special Italian cream cake on gourmet food marketplace Gold Belly.
It’s recipe has been perfected for over 70 years and is one of the top sellers in their Boston bakery.
This cake features sponge cake that’s been soaked in a secret rum syrup. It’s then filled with layers of rich Italian chocolate and vanilla custard and frosted with real whipped cream.
For the finishing touch, shaved white and dark chocolate is added to the top and more buttercream for good measure.
All of the treats offered at Montilio’s Baking Company are made the old-fashioned way, by hand and only use simple, first class ingredients.
BUY: You can check out more information about Montilio’s Baking Company and order your own Legendary Italian Rum Cake for delivery on their Gold Belly page here.
Summary
You’ve got some great options when it comes to shopping for the best Italian cream cake for delivery online.
Our number one pick is at 3 Brothers Bakery and their classic Italian Cream Cake. It’s made with a traditional recipe and elegantly decorated with cream cheese rosettes and pecan halves.
At a close second, Grandma’s Italian Cream Cake from Iron Chef Cat Cora would satisfy any die hard Italian cream cake fan. It’s not necessarily big in size at just 6-inches across, but it’s dense and heavy, weighing in at 4.5lbs.
Soulfully Yours Bakery offers the best looking and WOW Italian cream cake on this top list.
They just make some incredible cakes!
Their version of an Italian cream cake is authentically made, using a century old recipe from an Italian patisserie owner in Italy.
Maybe you’re looking for something a bit different? Then you should check out Rustkia Cafe and Bakery and their Italian Caramel Cream Cake. It’s a traditional Italian cream cake (aka Italian wedding cake) with super moist vanilla caramel cake packed full of walnuts.
The outside is a caramel buttercream frosting and rolled in lightly toasted coconut shreds.
Another good Italian style cake with a twist but without the nuts is from Montilio’s Baking Company and their Legendary Italian Rum cake.
This is perfect for those who aren’t a fan of nuts, but still want an Italian cream cake for a special event or celebration.
At Montilio’s, their Legendary Italian Rum Cake features sponge cake that’s been soaked in their special secret rum syrup and filled with rich Italian chocolate and creamy vanilla custard.
It’s a best seller and would be an awesome alternative if you’re catering to guests that prefer a nut free Italian cake or can’t eat nuts for dietary or allergy reasons.
Hopefully these top picks for the best Italian cream cake for delivery online have helped you find the perfect Italian cream cake for your next event!
