Tiramisu is more of an artform than a cake flavor.
The Italian dessert has to have the right ingredients, mixed the right way and combined the right way.
The espresso coffee soaks the light sponge cake or ladyfingers and the rich mascarpone cheese combines for an out of this world flavor that’s utterly unique to Tiramisu.
Italians call lady fingers savoiardi.
• Best celebration tiramisu for delivery @ Bake Me A Wish! | $52
• Most high end mail order tiramisu @ Maialino’s | $84
• Over the top tiramisu @ Rustika Cafe and Bakery | $99
• Least hassle, easy shipping Tiramisu @ Amazon | Check Price
• Big tiramisu @ Mackenzie Ltd | $64.95
• Vegan tiramisu @ The Naked Bar | $84
• Alternative tiramisu in a jar @ Soul Sweet Boutique | $24+
There’s over a dozen places online that deliver tiramisu nationwide, each one having their own recipe and baking method. We’ve picked out the best of the best.
Scroll through this ultimate tiramisu for delivery roundup and pick out your favorite.
Ferrara Bakery
Ferrara Bakery have been perfecting their tiramisu from NYC’s Little Italy since 1892. All they do is Italian desserts and this tiramisu cake is top rated for a reason.
The tiramisu cake features homemade savoiardi (ladyfingers) that soaked in deep, rich espresso and coffee liqueur and layer it all together with their signature sweet mascarpone.
For servings, it’s advertised at between 10-12 people and measures 8-inches across.
BUY: To check out more information about Ferrara Bakery and order your own tiramisu cake, see their Gold Belly page here.
Bake Me A Wish!
Bake Me A Wish! takes the number two spot with their Tiramisu Classico cake. They’re featured quite a bit on Treat Buyer and for good reason.
They’ve got an excellent selection of high quality, top rated cakes that come with a special cake gift box and personalized greeting card.
You can select the occasion – from birthdays, to thank you to I’m sorry – or just no occasion at all – and Bake Me A Wish! will take care of packaging and shipping your gift to the lucky recipient…unless you’re the lucky one 🙂
For their Tiramisu Classico cake, Bake Me A Wish! have taken two layers of espresso coffee soaked cake and fill them with a light buttercream.
On top, you’ll find rich, creamy coffee whipped cream and dark chocolate and cocoa sprinkles.
It has all the trademarks of a classic tiramisu that’s been upscaled into a birthday cake style. It’s ideal for gatherings since you can portion the cake into individual slices. The addition of a “Happy Birthday” cake topper is the finishing touch.
Not shopping for a birthday? You can order this cake without the cake topper, too.
Bake Me A Wish! makes it easy to deliver a birthday or special occasion treat in just a few clicks. They’ll take care of everything, from baking, packing, shipping and delivering to pretty much anywhere in America.
The extra bonuses of a gift box and personalized greeting card really make it the complete package and something you should consider when you’re looking to send a tiramisu cake to someone.
BUY: Check out more information about Bake Me A Wish! and order your own Tiramisu Classico Cake, check out their website here.
Maialino
One of the more pricier gourmet tiramisu’s on our top list, Maialino is a Roman-style trattoria that specializes in Italian cuisine.
You can get a tray of their hand made tiramisu and enjoy their top rated treat. The tray measures 7″ – 13″” and will serve 6-8 people…or you a couple of times!
If you need a gourmet tiramisu cake quickly, this could be ideal as the bakery offers fast 2-day shipping.
Just so you know, Gold Belly doesn’t actually make and ship the tiramisu cakes, they’re more like a marketplace that showcases a lot of different treats from many bakeries and restaurants around America.
When you buy this tiramisu cake, it’ll be made and shipped directly from Maialino. You’ll get a box and some flyers inside with the Gold Belly logo, but it’s absolutely authentically made by a gourmet bakery.
BUY: Check out more information about Maialino and order your own tiramisu on their Gold Belly page here.
Williams Sonoma
Williams-Sonoma probably isn’t the first place you’d look for cakes, but they have a surprising selection of top rated treats.
Did you know tiramisu translated into English literally means pick me up or cheer me up?
The idea is that it’s presented at the end of a meal to hopefully cheer you up.
I like that idea!
The tiramisu cake at Williams-Sonoma is made by a bakery out of Chicago called Eli’s Cheesecake Co.
It has more of the traditional tiramisu form and not so much a “birthday cake” style. This is a good option if you still need a decent sized tiramisu but prefer the typical form you know and love.
They’ve made an extra creamy version of a tiramisu by using moist cake rounds of delicate espresso soaked sponge cake. Each round is layered with lightly sweetened mascarpone cheese and sweet cream.
For delivery, the tiramisu is delivered frozen, and you’ll get a packet of cocoa powder to dust the top with for a final finish.
Each tiramisu measures 9-inches across and serves 12-14 people, plenty for your get together and there might even be a slice or two left over for seconds.
BUY: Check out more information about this tiramisu and order your own, head to their page on the Williams-Sonoma website here.
Rustika Cafe and Bakery
This tiramisu cake from Rustica Cafe and Bakery looks amazing!
If you love tiramisu at all, your mouth should be watering right about now. Did you see that gold bow too?
Rustkia Cafe and Bakery have made this incredible tiramisu cake that features three layers of vanilla cake that have been soaked in a bold homemade Italian espresso and coffee liquor blend.
In between the cake are thick mascarpone style icing layers and the entire cake has lady fingers and chocolate ganache decorating the outside.
The bakery was founded in the early 1990’s and is known as one of the best cake shops and bakeries in Houston.
This is one of the more decorative and WOW tiramisu cakes on this top list and it’ll be an excellent choice of you want to impress the recipient on their special day.
The question is, where do you start? Do you slice the tiramisu cake between the lady fingers, or do you pull off a lady finger and use it to scoop up the tiramisu goodness from your plate?
I think either way would work and be a whole heartedly enjoyed.
BUY: Check out more information about Rustika Café and bakery, and order your own tiramisu cake (with free shipping) on their Gold Belly page here.
Mackenzie Limited
Check out this BIG tiramisu cake from Mackenzie Limited.
They’ve used alternating layers of imported Mascarpone and moist sponge cake and soaked it in bold espresso and a splash of coffee liquor.
You’ll get a really warm and flavorful taste in each bite. It’s traditionally made, rather than being more of a birthday cake style like you saw earlier on this top list.
It’s a light cake that’s perfect for rounding off your meal at your next event or celebration.
A best seller from Mackenzie Ltd, it measures 10-inches across and comes pre-sliced to serve up to 14 people. It’s one of the biggest tiramisu cakes we’ve seen and definitely should be considered if you’re planning a bigger get together.
BUY: Check out more information about Mackenzie Ltd and order your own tiramisu cake for delivery on their website here.
Amazon
So I wanted to show you some options on Amazon incase you’re in a pinch – in both time and money.
Amazon can really be helpful if you need something fast and at a good price.
You might not get a truly authentic gourmet experience, but you’ll get a great tasting tiramisu cake at a great price.
Here are a few of your options on Amazon for tiramisu cake delivery.
Oasis Café
How about something a little different but perhaps even more delicious than a traditional tiramisu?
This tiramisu cheesecake from Oasis Café is a show stopper!
Oasis Cafe, out of Queens, New York offers this tiramisu cheesecake that’s brushed with bold espresso and filled with ultra creamy, rich coffee mascarpone cream.
It’s complete indulgence in every bite!
Inside, the vanilla cheesecake is flavored with espresso and layered with ladyfingers – dipped in more espresso – all around the center.
For the finishing touches, the tiramisu cheesecake is chilled and then smothered with velvety smooth white chocolate whipped topping and covered in cocoa powder.
If you want a rich, bold tiramisu cheesecake, this is the one to get.
BUY: Check out more information about Oasis Café and order your own mail order tiramisu cheesecake, head to their Gold Belly page here.
The Naked Bar
If you’re vegan, this is also a cheesecake tiramisu, but it’s made by The Naked Bar – a gourmet food company that specializes in raw vegan desserts that are free of artificial and processed ingredients.
The company started in 2018 and has been impressing palettes ever since.
This is a smaller tiramisu – perfect for a small get together of 6-8 people and measures 6-inches across.
It’s difficult to find a specialty tiramisu cake like this, considering all the cream cheese that’s typically incorporated into it. This is a good option if you or the special person follows a vegan diet.
BUY: Check out more information about The Naked Bar and order your own vegan tiramisu cheesecake on their Gold Belly page here.
Soul Sweet Boutique
A different take on a classic Italian dessert, these are tiramisu cakes in a jar and are perfect for single-serve and individual celebrations.
Actually, they’re perfect for anytime. You don’t need a special occasion to enjoy these. They’re awesome!…I just wish they’d use a five gallon bucket instead of a jar 🙂
Soul Sweet Boutique makes a range of really tasty desserts in a jar – I know you’re here to see tiramisu, but these flavors really are something to marvel at!
- Strawberries and Creme
- Lime Cheesecake
- Churros Cake
- Carrot Chocolate
- Coconut
- Red Velvet
- Pineapple Creme
- Berry Cheesecake
- Guava Cheesecake
- Strawberry Cheesecake
- + more!
For their tiramisu in a jar, they’ve taken layers of rich smooth mascarpone coffee cream and smothered it on their homemade ladyfinger cookies.
These are perfect for single-serve or smaller celebrations and events. Maybe a little too expensive to buy every guest their own tiramisu in a jar, but a wonderful alternative to a traditional cake.
BUY: Check out more information about Soul Sweet Boutique and order your own tiramisu in a jar on their website here.
Summary
You’ve got some great options when it comes to finding the best bakeries online that deliver tiramisu.
Our number one pick for tiramisu delivery online goes to Ferrara Bakery in NYC’s Little Italy.
It’s authentically Italian and made with premium ingredients for an unmatched taste.
The master bakers take their homemade savoiardi (Italian for ladyfingers) and soak them in a bold espresso and coffee liqueur. The coffee flavor is balanced perfectly with their sweet mascarpone cream for a dreamy taste.
Ferrara Bakery is the place to get an authentic Italian tiramisu delivered online.
If you’re shopping for to send someone a tiramisu online for a birthday or other celebration, Bake Me A Wish! might be more appropriate.
They offer a more traditional cake-style tiramisu with two layers of espresso coffee soaked cake and light coffee buttercream.
What makes Bake Me A Wish! a great place to shop for celebration cakes – they include a cake gift box and a personalized greeting card for free.
So when you send the cake to someone, they’ll receive a cooled shipping box, with a really nice cake gift box and personalized card inside.
Not many other bakeries do that.
Bake Me A Wish! will set you up to deliver an amazing cake gift and it’s our choice when it comes to celebration and event gourmet tiramisu cake.
When you want to try one of the most high-end and expensive tiramisu’s online for delivery, see the bakers at Maialino’s trattoria, an Italian restaurant that prides it’s self on serving simple, real food.
Their tiramisu features espresso soaked Pavensini cookies that are layered with whipped mascarpone and cocoa cream.
Williams-Sonoma has a solid tiramisu that’s made by Eli’s Cheesecake Co. It’s top rated and is classically made with espresso, mascarpone cheese and sweet cream.
Our recommendation for an over-the-top tiramisu cake for an individual or really small get-together goes to Rustika Cafe and Bakery.
They offer a mini tiramisu cake with three layers of vanilla cake, soaked in a rich homemade Italian espresso and coffee liquor.
With thick mascarpone icing and chocolate ganache on the outside, it’s finished with a line of ladyfingers around the edge.
This would be an extra special treat for an individual on their birthday, or maybe a couple celebrating an important anniversary.
Mackenzie Limited has a classic tiramisu cake that’s able to serve up to 14 people. It’s one of the larger tiramisu cakes we’ve featured on this top list and is our recommendation for a mail order tiramisu cake for large gatherings.
Maybe you’re in a crunch for time and money? Amazon can help.
They offer three different tiramisu cakes that often can be delivered in two hours. They’re budget priced – under $20 and if you’re an Amazon prime member, you can get delivery free.
The tiramisu cakes offered at Amazon wont be as grand and come with the same fanfare…but they’ll be affordable, delivered quick and not bad tasting.
If you’re shopping for a tiramisu cake for a celebration, you could really surprise (and delight) someone when they see you got them a tiramisu cheesecake from Oasis Cafe.
It takes all the best bits of a traditional tiramisu cake and adds in delicious creamy espresso flavored vanilla cheesecake.
You have a good vegan tiramisu mail order cake at The Naked Bar. It’s a smaller cake and will serve 6-8 people, but oozes flavor and is free of artificial and processed ingredients.
Finally, for a different option, check out Soul Sweet Boutique and their tiramisu in a jar. I’d recommend these for smaller get togethers as they’re a bit pricey as you’re paying per jar – but for a couple or 4-6 people, it would be a fun dessert and a different take on a classic treat.
Hopefully these recommendations have helped you find your perfect mail order tiramisu for delivery and your event or celebration goes awesome!
