If you’re searching for the best bakeries online that deliver Key lime pie to any doorstep in America, you’re in the right place.
You’ll see the best options available, how much they cost and what you can expect when you open the shipping box.
• Big key lime pies from Little Pie Company | $79 + Free Shipping
• Best value Key lime pie @ 3 Brother’s Bakery or Key Lime Pie Co | $22.99/$24.99
• Most selection of premium Key lime pies @ Gold Belly | $Varies
Key Lime Pies are the perfect balance of juicy, tart Key limes and sweet creamy filling. Unfortunately, making a real authentic Key lime pie can be a bit of a task on your own….but worry not!
Here are the top bakeries that will do the hard work and bake, pack and deliver a fresh Key Lime Pie to your doorstep. All you have to do is open the box and dig in!
Goldbelly
Goldbelly is an online marketplace that features small bakeries and restaurants and their gourmet foods.
They’ve teamed up so that these small businesses can offer their premium treats nationwide.
They feature all sorts of things like ice cream to pizzas, brownies, cakes….and also Key lime pies!
They actually have about 30 Key lime foods – not only covering Key lime pies, but also Key lime bundt cakes, Key lime cheesecakes, Key lime ice cream and more.
Here are the top choices on Gold Belly that deliver Key Lime Pie to almost any doorstep in the USA.
The first Key Lime Pie you should see is this top rated and best selling option from Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe.
Kermit’s bakery is located in the heart of Key West and they make each Key Lime pie in house.
Using the freshest Key lime juice and fluffy whipped cream, these pies are about as authentic as it gets.
Making Key Lime Pies has been something Kermit Carpenter perfected since 1993, so it’s no wonder they have rave reviews from very satisfied bellies!
BUY: Check out more information about Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe and order your own Key Lime Pie on their Gold Belly page here.
A generous sized Key lime pie from Little Pie Company – this comfortably serves 8-10 people and measures 10″ across.
In every pie goes real Key lime juice and the filling is rich, smooth and creamy. The crust is made from a buttery crumble gramahm cracker.
The Little Pie Company is based in NYC and first started out as a side hustle for Broadway actor Arnold Wilkerson. His bakery business bloomed and the rest is history.
Price includes free shipping with ice packs to make sure it arrives in top condition.
BUY: Check out more information on Little Pie Company and order your own Key lime pie on their Gold Belly page here.
Check out this Key lime pie from Carousel Cakes.
Key lime pies are quite simple in terms of ingredients, but it’s the simplicity that requires only the best quality ingredients to be used because they are so few of them.
At Carousel Cakes, they make every cake and pie by hand and use their five decades of baking expertise to create their Key lime pies.
Their cakes are so darn tasty that they’ve been featured by Oprah on her “O” list and even on “The View” with Barbara Walters. Oh, and Instyle Magazine, Time Out, New York Magazine and ABC News too!
Did I mention it’s also Kosher certified?
BUY: Check out more information on Carousel Cakes and order your own Key lime pie on their Gold Belly page here.
The last Key Lime Pie option from Gold Belly is from Blue Smoke. Usually famous for their BBQ fare, their Key lime pies are now shipping nationwide via the Gold Belly marketplace.
Enjoy fresh Key lime juice, creamy condensed milk and a rich butter crust. The pie will serve 8-10 people and measures 9-inches across.
BUY: Check out more information on Blue Smoke and order your own Key lime pie on their Goldbelly page here.
Key Lime Pie Co
Key Lime Pie Co are experts at Key limes! They make an array of Key lime goodies, but also offer a traditional Key lime pie that ticks all the boxes.
It’s creamy, tart, rich and handmade. The crust is Graham Cracker and it’s finished with home made whipped cream topping.
They pride themselves on using premium natural ingredients and make sure each pie is made with care.
BUY: Check out more information on Key Lime Pie Co and order your own Key lime pie on their website here.
Joe’s Stone Crab
Usually associated with their premium stone crab claws, Joe’s Stone Crab also offers a gourmet Key lime pie that can be delivered overnight to most of the US.
Their Key lime pies are baked fresh daily and measure 9-inches across. Each pie will comfortably serve 6-8 people and even arrives at your door ready to serve.
You can specify an exact delivery date upon ordering, so you might only have to keep it in the fridge for a short while before you serve it to your guests.
BUY: Check out more information on Joe’s Stone Crab and order your own Key lime pie for delivery on their website here.
3 Brother’s Bakery
This award winning Key lime pie from Three Brother’s Bakery can be shipped to any doorstep.
Their Key lime pie came 1st in it’s category at the 2017 National Pie Championship in Florida. The home of Key lime! That’s an achievement.
Each Key lime pie is started with their own graham cracker crust and filled with their homemade secret Key lime recipe.
Naturally, they add swirls of homemade whipped cream and finish with Key lime zest. Delish!
BUY: Check out more information about Three Brother’s Bakery and order your own Key lime pie on their website here.
Bake Me A Wish!
Bake Me A Wish! is featured quite a bit here on Treat Buyer. They offer some great choices of desserts and one of them happens to be this 8-inch fresh Key lime pie.
The bakers use a delicious meringue that’s pied high ontop of a creamy rich Key lime custard.
The Key lime pies are shipped in a ultra giftable gift box and even comes with a greeting card that you can customize online.
BUY: Check out more information about Bake Me A Wish! and order your own Key lime pie on their website here.
Roundup
You’ve got some great options when it comes to finding the best Key lime pies for delivery.
Our #1 recommendation is to check out Gold Belly. Their gourmet food marketplace has several really good options for Key Lime Pies.
They are on the more expensive side – so be prepared for that – but you’ll be getting an ultra authentic Key lime pie that will taste amazing.
For a bigger key lime pie, check out Little Pie Company, also on Goldbelly. They serve between 8-10 people and have top reviews from satisfied buyers.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie on Gold Belly is a great choice and they’ve been perfecting Key lime pie recipes literally decades.
The best value Vs quality can be found at Key Lime Pie Co and 3 Brother’s Bakery.
They offer a Key lime pie for $24.99 or $22.99 and both have a reputation for their quality. 3 Brother’s won an 1st place award for their Key lime pie and Key Lime Pie Co are experts at creating Key lime desserts using their 100-year old recipes.
While you’re here, check out these awesome mouth watering treats for delivery
