If you’re shopping for your next favorite treat, sometimes all you want is a little sample so you can literally get a taste of what it’s like.
Buying a full size cake, for example, at a gourmet bakery online can be priced as much as $45 to $75 or even more.
A cookie or brownie gift box can be $40 and up.
What happens if you don’t like them?
Fortunately there are some excellent bakeries and dessert makers that provide sampler packs of their goodies so you can try out their items before you make a final decision and buy the full sized version.
- Best banana pudding sampler pack at Magnolia Bakery | $45 – $70
- Best cheesecake sampler pack at Junior’s Cheesecake | $84.95 + Free Shipping
- Best pie sampler pack at Little Pie Company | $59.95 + Free Shipping
- Best rum bundt cake sampler pack at Dockside Market | $79.95+ Free Shipping
- Best bakery assortment sampler pack at Harry & David | $69.99
- Best baklava sampler pack at Amazon | Check Price
- Best cake sampler pack at Carlo’s Bakery | $74.95
- Best cupcake sampler pack at Baked By Melissa | $34
Let’s check out the best places online that deliver sampler packs nationwide!
The Best Dessert Sampler Packs You Can Buy
Magnolia Bakery
#1 Banana Pudding In America
Best Of Magnolia Bakery Sampler Pack
Magnolia Bakery has a high reputation for their top rated treats. Their bakery in New York City is a mini landmark and a favorite place to visit by people looking for a sweet fix.
They’ve got some amazing desserts and are famous for their banana pudding, piled high in their signature Magnolia Bakery cups.
You can buy their “Best of Magnolia Sampler Pack” to try their treats for yourself and they’ll deliver it right to your home.
They actually have two sampler packs offered year round, and they often add seasonal sampler packs for special occasions like Mother’s Day and around the holidays.
Magnolia Bakery’s Small Sampler Pack
Their most affordable sampler pack features two of their world famous large classic banana pudding cups – creamy vanilla pudding folded with vanilla wafers and fresh bananas.
You’ll also get two cupcakes to try in a rich chocolate and vanilla strawberry flavor. They’re intentionally picked to be at opposite ends of the flavor spectrum so you can get a feel (or taste) of Magnolia Bakery’s gourmet treats.
Magnolia Bakery offers this sampler in a “small” ($45) or “family” ($60) size. The family size includes 4 large classic banana pudding cups and six assorted cupcakes.
Magnolia Bakery’s Large Sampler Pack
Magnolia Bakery doesn’t just make killer cupcakes and banana pudding, they’re experts at baking gourmet brownies too. You can buy this larger sampler pack and really get the Magnolia Bakery experience in your own home.
It’s called the “Best of Magnolia Bakery” Baked Fresh Sampler Pack and features a classic pack ($75) with six large banana pudding cups and four buttery blondies and four chocolate chewy brownies.
If you want to see what all the fuss is about with their world famous banana pudding, choose the variety pack ($80).
You’ll still get six large cups of banana pudding, but with three different flavors like red velvet, chocolate hazelnut and classic banana pudding. It still comes with the brownie and blondie combo.
This is our pick if you can’t make it to the store in person – you WILL want more, so do yourself a favor and put the larger sampler pack to your cart and checkout ASAP.
BUY: See more information about Magnolia Bakery and order your own sampler pack on their website here.
Goldbelly
#1 Gourmet Food Marketplace
Junior’s Favorites Mini Cheesecake Sampler Pack
Goldbelly is an excellent place to explore new foods. You’ll find lots of small businesses that make BIG tasting dessert sampler packs.
There are too many to list in this one article, but here are the best ones we think you should check out.
Junior’s Cheesecake is a New York, Brooklyn landmark, and they’ve been creating their highly rated cheesecakes since the bakery was founded in 1950.
They have an almost overwhelming list of gourmet cheesecake flavors and it can be hard to decide which one you should choose.
This sampler is the best way to get a feel of Junior’s Cheesecake flavors without committing to just one.
It features three of their best selling flavors – Raspberry Swirl, Red Velvet Cheesecake and Devils Food Cheesecake. You’ll get 6 of each for a total of 18 mini cheesecakes.
This is actually an awesome option if you’re planning a party, dinner or get-together. Each person can choose their favorite Junior’s Cheesecake and you won’t have to worry about slicing up a big cheesecake accurately into enough portions. It would be embarrassing if you’re a portion or two short 🙁
For delivery, the cheesecakes are packed in a custom fit cooler with a frozen ice pack and then places into a branded corrugated box. It’s all shrink wrapped to preserve freshness and to make sure you only get the best cheesecakes on the planet. They’re shipped FREE.
Junior’s Cheesecakes are certified Kosher-Dairy under the supervision of Kof-K.
BUY: Check out more information about Junior’s Cheesecakes and order your own Mini Cheesecake Sampler on their Goldbelly page here.
Little Pie Company Sampler Pack
Little Pie Company prides its self with scratch made pies, baked daily using the highest quality, natural ingredients sourced from local farms.
It wasn’t long ago that you had to physically visit their popular bakery in person to enjoy their pies, until Goldbelly put them on the virtual map by adding them to their gourmet food marketplace.
Now, you can get a best selling assortment of Little Pie Company’s classic shipped straight to your doorstep and try out their pies for yourself.
Just a warning….you’ll be hooked!
This four pie selection includes these gourmet flavors:
- Old Fashioned Apple Pie
- Decadent Mississippi Mud Pie
- Tangy Key Lime Pie
- Signature Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie
Little Pie Company was originally just a side business for an aspiring Broadway actor back in 1985. Since then it’s blossomed to a popular destination for some of the nation’s most sought after treats.
BUY: Check out more information about Little Pie Company and order your own Little Pie Sampler Pack on their Goldbelly page here.
Dockside Market
Rum infused bundt cakes
This is a sampler pack you definitely have to try. It’s a top rated dessert sampler on Goldbelly and is as unique as it is delicious.
Dockside Market hails from Key Large and was founded in 1978. They’ve been offering an amazing selection of gourmet bundt cakes, cookies and brownies for the last four decades and now you can get your hand (or tastebuds) on them via Goldbelly.
Their boozy inspired mini bundt cake sampler pack features twelve individual tropically inspired bundt cakes in three unique summer-themed flavors:
- 4 x Strawberry Daiquiri Mini Bundt Cakes – A sweet strawberry cake that’s infused with Caribbean Rum.
- 4 x Pina Colada Mini Bundt Cakes – A blend of pineapple and coconut finished off with a Caribbean rum glaze
- 4 Island Rum Mini Bundt Cakes – A nutty pecan crunchiness with a splash of rum
Each mini bundt cake is individually wrapped in a branded box, opening the door to giving these as gifts to people who have everything…almost!
The mini bundt cakes arrive ready to serve, but you can always put them in your freezer where they’ll stay fresh for up to 6 months.
They won’t last that long after you’ve had a bite, though…
BUY: Check out more information about Dockside Market and order your own mini rum bundt cakes on their Goldbelly page here.
Harry & David
#1 Bakery Assortment Sampler Pack
Signature Bakery Assortment Sampler Pack
Harry & David are experts at baking sweet treats. They have an amazing selection that seems to never end…making it difficult to choose the best single item that you’re looking for.
This is their signature bakery assortment sampler pack that features 11 unique bakery treats. It’s an excellent way to sample Harry & David’s offerings before committing to a full sized version.
When you order this, you’ll be getting a whole range of Harry & David bakery goodies, fresh from their Southern Oregon bakery:
- Pineapple Macadamia Nut Cake
- Wolferman’s® lemon poppyseed coffee cake
- Apple streusel loaf cake
- Cinnamon swirl
- Baklava
- Raspberry galettes
- Lemon shortbread cookies
- Double chocolate chunk cookies
- Walnut chocolate chunk cookie
- Moose Munch® cookies
- Macadamia nut chocolate chip cookies
The sampler pack includes Harry & David’s most popular treats and absolutely is the way to go if you need a taste of what the full sized versions are like before you order.
Maybe you just need a variety of baked goodies for a party or celebration? This is the way to go and would look AMAZING on your dining room table, or display table at a party.
Everyone can help themselves to their favorite treats and come back for another bite!
BUY: Check out more information about Harry & David and order your own signature bakery assortment sampler pack on their website here.
Milk Bar
#1 Birthday Treat Sampler Pack
The Milk Bar Sampler Pack
Milk Bar is featured quite a bit here on Treat Buyer. They hold the record for the highest rated birthday cakes we’ve ever seen – their classic birthday cake has over 10,930+ reviews!
They’re also really good at making other birthday themed treats and you can get a sampler pack of their best ones packed up in a super giftable tin gift box.
This is Milk Bar’s Sampler tin and it features four delicious treats that make it easy to get a first hand taste of what the bakery is all about. It features:
- Birthday Truffles
- Chocolate Birthday Truffles
- A Slice Of Milk Bar Pie
- Assorted Cookies (various flavors like their unique compost cookie or blueberry & cream cookie)
The tin gift box and bright packaging are lovely and it really adds a special touch to this sweet treat sampler pack.
Buy it and have it shipped to your home to give as a gift, or just ship it directly to the lucky recipient and they’ll have a wonderful surprise waiting for them on their doorstep!
BUY: Check out more information about Milk Bar and order your own Milk Bar Sampler Tin on their website here.
Amazon
#1 Baklava Sampler Online
Luxury Baklava Sampler Pack
Baklava takes a skillful hand to curate, but is one of the most richest and flavorful treats you can find.
Amazon has this awesome mixed baklava sampler pack that features no less than seven different varieties of buttery rich baklava. They all feature puff pastry that’s carefully rolled around assorted pistachios, pine nuts, walnuts and cashew fillings.
They have a homemade taste and are all freshly prepared using the best ingredients the expert pastry chefs can find.
You have a choice of four sizes – all with seven different types of baklava. Choose from 11 pieces, 30, 55 or even 90. This would make a stunning display at a party or get together. When did you last see a baklava buffet???
BUY: Check out more information about this baklava sampler pack and buy on their Amazon page here.
Etsy
#1 Cake Sampler In America
Carlo’s Bakery Best Seller’s Cake Slice Sampler
Carlo’s Bakery was shot into stardom on their hit Food Network TV show “Cake Boss”.
It featured the day-to-day goings on at their popular bakery and showcasing the amazing cakes they were challenged to create.
Now you can get the ultimate “Cake Boss” sampler pack from Carlo’s Bakery on Etsy!
You’ll get 8 amazing slices of Carlo’s Bakery’s best selling flavors:
- Rainbow – Six layers of rainbow colored vanilla cake with sweet vanilla icing and rainbow sprinkles
- Strawberry Pastel Rainbow – Six layers of pastel rainbow colored vanilla cake filled with a sweet strawberry buttercream icing
- Carrot – Freshly shredded carrots and finely chopped walnuts, frosted with cream cheese icing
- Red Velvet – Moist cake and cream cheese frosting, finished with chocolate shavings and crumbles of red velvet cake
- Confetti – Vanilla cake with a burst or sprinkles, layered with vanilla confetti icing and topped with rainbow sprinkles
- Rainbow Chocolate Fudge – Six layers of rainbow colored vanilla cake with a rich chocolate fudge frosting and covered with rainbow sprinkles
- Cookies & Cream – Chocolate cake layers, iced with cookies and cream Swiss buttercream. Finished with Oreos and chocolate ganache
- Chocolate Fudge – Chocolate cake iced with rich chocolate fudge frosting and topped with chocolate ganache. Finished with chocolate sprinkles
This is an awesome gift idea for a cake-a-holic or even just trying it for yourself to see what all the buzz is about at Carlo’s Bakery.
BUY: Check out more information about Carlo’s Bakery Best Seller’s Cake Slice Sampler Pack and order your own on their Etsy page here.
Eli’s Cheesecake
Mini Cheesecake Bites
Cutie Dessert Sampler Pack
This cutie dessert sampler pack from Eli’s Cheesecake features bite-size desserts of their most popular flavors. You’ll get 4 mini bitesizsed portions of the uniquely delicious cheesecakes to try them out and choose your favorite.
- Raspberry Macaroon Bar – All butter shortbread crust filled with coconut custard and topped with red raspberry puree and a sprinkle of coconut
- Pecan Bar – Crunchy toasted pecans and a sweet custard filling, baked on a butter shortbread cookie crust
- 7-Layer Bar – Pecans and bittersweet chocolate chunks, smothered in a custardy coconut filling and topped with crunchy sugar and even more coconut
The mini bites are shipped frozen in a heavy duty styrofoam container to make sure they arrive in perfect condition. Leave them out at room temperature for a few hours to defrost before serving.
BUY: Check out more information about Eli’s Cheesecakes and order your own Cutie Dessert Sampler Pack on their website here.
Baked By Melissa
#1 cupcake sampler in America
Latest & Greatest Cupcake Sampler Pack
The final sampler pack you should check out is from Baked By Melissa.
The bakery specializes in cupcakes and they have a mind boggling amount of flavor varieties to choose from.
Fortunately, you can pick up a sampler pack of their most popular cupcake flavors to try out before you make your final decision on which ones to get for your next celebration or event.
Their “Latest & Greatest Cupcakes” sampler pack features a 25 pack with 12 unique flavors to try:
- Tie-Dye
- Cookie & Cream
- Peanut Butter & Jelly
- Cookie Dough
- Triple Chocolate Fudge
- Chocolate Chip Pancake
- Red Velvet
- Mint Cookie
- Cookie Butter Bliss
- Double Chocolate Cookie Dough
- Confetti Cookie Doug
- Vanilla Fluff
You’ll get two of each, with an extra “Vanilla Fluff” to make a total of 25.
This would make an awesome display on a dessert buffet table or you could blow someone’s mind and give the entire 25 as a gift. There’s bound to be a flavor (or two) they absolutely LOVE.
BUY: Check out more information about Baked By Melissa and order your own Latest & Greatest Cupcake sampler pack on their website here.
Summary
You’ve got some great options when it comes to shopping for the best dessert sampler packs for delivery.
For a top quality and delicious treat, head over to Magnolia Bakery and try their Best of Magnolia Sampler Pack.
Their banana pudding alone is worth the price, but you’ll also get to try their amazing cupcakes that somehow taste even better than they look. You should probably go for the large size because you’ll be kicking yourself that you didn’t once you get to the bottom of the banana pudding cup.
Magnolia Bakery also has a larger sampler pack that includes their out of this world brownies and blondies. A great gift idea or dessert sampler pack that will be very well received by pretty much anyone with a tongue and tastebuds.
Goldbelly is an amazing place to shop for dessert sampler packs.
This article could have been filled with many small businesses that make dessert sampler packs from their marketplace alone.
The top three options to check out all have their own unique take on a sampler pack, but they all score equally high on quality and taste.
Junior’s Cheesecake offers it’s Junior’s Favorites Mini Cheesecake Sampler Pack that’s perfect for medium sized get togethers and dessert buffet tables.
People can choose their favorite flavor and indulge in their own personally made mini cheesecake. No worrying about portion control or slicing up the cheesecake wrong.
You’ll get 12 perfectly made mini cheesecakes that are plate-scrapingly delicious. Did you see the Raspberry Swirl??? HELLO!
The second choice on Goldbelly goes to the Little Pie Company and their little pie sampler pack.
It features four masterfully made dessert pies that cover the entire spectrum of dessert flavors – apple, chocolate, key lime and sour cream apple walnut. If you were to gift this to someone they’ll be thanking you for the rest of eternity. When was the last time you received four amazing dessert pies on your doorstep?
For something completely different, head to Dockside Market also on Goldbelly. Their mini rum bundt cake sampler pack is a boozy take on a totally tropical dessert. Dockside Market offers three flavors – strawberry daiquiri, piña colada and island rum.
It’s difficult to decide which one to try first…..gift this to someone and they won’t have to worry about deciding – they can try them ALL.
If you’re looking for strictly baked goodies in a sampler pack, Harry & David are always a top choice here on Treat Buyer. Their signature bakery assortment sampler pack is top rated by over 140+ people and features no less than eleven individual bakery desserts.
We recommend this if you’re looking to spoil someone or if you want to setup a dessert buffet table and have an epic spread of a variety of desserts.
It would look amazing and people can choose their favorite..and then come back for a second one when they’re done!
Milk Bar has a very giftable “Milk Bar Sampler” that features four of their best selling treats neatly packaged inside a gift tin. It’s top rated by over 965+ people and makes for the perfect gift if you’re looking to treat someone. You won’t get to try their cakes (which they’re famous for), but you will get to try their truffles, cookies and pie.
Baklava is hard to make but when it’s done right, the end result is delicious!
Amazon is the place to go for the best baklava sampler.
You’ll get seven different varieties and you can order a small gift box with 11 pieces all the way up to a super size gift box with 90 pieces. The baklava is traditionally Turkish made and features pistachio’s, pine nuts, walnuts and cashews. It’s buttery delicious and very presentable in it’s gift box.
One thing to note – the baklava pieces are individually wrapped and sealed for freshness, so you can grab one or two and not worry about the entire lot going stale after a week.
They’ll stay good until you’re ready to enjoy them.
Etsy is home to a lot of dessert sampler packs. One of the best is from “Cake Boss” Carlo’s Bakery and their Best Sellers’ Cake Slice Sampler.
It’s a bit pricey – at about $75 – but, hey, it’s the cake boss!
You’ll get eight unique cake slices that span the entire range of flavors from vanilla to chocolate to carrot to cookies and cream. This would be a fun alternative to a traditional birthday cake for smaller gatherings.
The lucky birthday recipient could choose their favorite flavor each day and they’d have over a week’s worth of cake desserts!
For an affordable cheesecake sampler pack, check out Eli’s Cheesecake and their Cutie Dessert Sample Pack. It includes three indulgent and skillfully made flavors that go beyond the typical “chocolate” or “vanilla” you’d find at your local grocery store. They’re bite size pieces, so maybe not the best option for a dessert, but for a gift, definitely. They will be able to sneak a mini cheesecake bite every now and then and enjoy the lush, rich flavors that each of them individually bring.
For a good cupcake variety sampler pack, Baked By Melissa is a good option. You’ll get twelve different cupcake flavors to try – a total of 25 cupcakes – for under $35. Imagine getting this and setting it up on a dessert table or bringing them out for your after dinner coffee. Each person could pick their favorite flavor and you’d still have enough left for everyone to get a second serving. If you need more than 25, Baked By Melissa offers the same twelve flavors in a 50 and even 100 pack.
No matter which place you choose to order your dessert sampler pack from we hope this guide has helped you narrow down the top choices. They’re all awesome, all you have to do is pick you favorite!
Some other delicious articles you need to check out:
