The 15 Best Dessert Subscription Boxes You Can Buy Right Now
Updated April 20th, 2022
Subscription Boxes deliver that Christmas morning feeling every month. You know it’s gonna be something good, but aren’t really sure what might be waiting for you to discover inside.
You can find subscription boxes for pretty much every interest – outdoors and camping, self care, art and of course sweet treats!
P.s. – Go to Crate Joy here for amazing subscription boxes for everyone!
• Best brownie dessert subscription box @ Brownie Of The Month Club On Etsy | $99 / 3 months
• Best fudge dessert subscription box @ Homemade Fudge Of The Month Club On Etsy | $60 / 3 Months
• Best chocolate dessert subscription box @ Jackie’s Chocolate | $99 / 3 months
• Best ice cream subscription box @ Jeni’s Ice Cream | $199 / 3 months
• Best dessert pie subscription box @ Gold Belly | $165 / 3 months
• Best variety dessert subscription box @ Phivi Artisanal Desserts | $124 / 3 months
Check out this epic roundup of the top dessert subscription boxes available for delivery right to your doorstep every month.
Etsy – Brownie Of The Month Club
Let’s kick off this list showcasing the best dessert subscription boxes online with this awesome Etsy shop.
They’ve got thousands of sales and have mastered baking gourmet brownies and delivering fresh, moist treats to America.
Made from scratch, Revolution 9 Bakery proudly creates all sorts of brownie flavors and offers a 3-month subscription plan for $99.
Each month you’ll receive a dozen 2″ brownies in your choice of flavor. This means you can make sure the brownies you get will be exactly to your liking.
Check out some of the flavors offered by this awesome Etsy shop:
- Classic Chocolate
- Chocolate Walnut
- Stuffed Reeses
- Reeses Pieces
- M&Ms Chocolate
- Red Velvet & Cream Cheese
- Creme de Menthe
- S’Mores Brownies
- Maple Bacon
- Buckeye Brownies
- Brownie Bombs
- Rocky Road Brownies
- Cookies n Cream
- Cosmic Brownies
- Reese’s Pretzel
- Reese’s S’Mores
Reviewers love this dessert subscription box!
Revolution 9 Bakery has racked up well over 1,200+ ratings and scoring a high 4.5/5 star average.
BUY: Check out more information about the Brownie Of The Month Club and order your own monthly dessert subscription on their Etsy page here.
CrateJoy – Phivi Artisanal Desserts Box
With this dessert subscription from Phivi box you’ll receive 8 freshly baked all natural desserts in fun and exciting themes.
This is a great way to try new flavors and desserts that you might not pick up at the store normally. 100+ people have rated this dessert subscription box 4.5/5 and they rave about how GOOD it tastes!
You’ll get to sample all sorts of desserts – that are always full size. The themes rotate each month, so you won’t get the same thing twice and be able to check out a whole range of treats.
Reviewers are raving about this dessert subscription box!
The treats are awesome, shipping is fast, the box arrives in great shape along with the contents, the value is great and people keep coming back for more.
Check out this unboxing and review on YouTube.
This makes an amazing gift idea too – who wouldn’t want delicious desserts arriving at their doorstep each month?
BUY: Check out more information about Phivi Artisanal Desserts and order your monthly dessert subscription box on their Crate Joy page here.
Fresh Baked Cookie Co
Ultimate Cookie Crate
If cookies are your go-to treat, this box from Fresh Baked Cookie Co might just be what you’re looking for. It’s a gourmet cookie mix subscription that comes with 2-3 fun surprises each month.
It’s a little different than the last two dessert subscription boxes as you’ll receive the raw ingredients to make some outstanding cookies! Each box has enough ingredients to make between 18-24 gourmet cookies.
You might have to add your own butter in some recipes, but all the other ingredients are pre-measured and high quality.
Fresh Baked Cookie Co. is also proud to only use locally sourced ingredients and they’ll include a 2-3 surprises in addition to the cookie mix. The surprises could be anything – like a cute new apron, fun themed pumpkin socks (to pair with their pumpkin spice cookies!)….they’ve even included Mexican hot chocolate room fragrance spray. Sounds amazing!
You’ll get step-by-step instructions that make it easy to bake delicious gourmet cookies right in your own home.
75+ people have rated this monthly dessert subscription box 4.5/5 and they love what they’re receiving each month. Reviewers comment that it’s well worth the price and they had a blast making the cookies.
BUY: Check out more information about Fresh Baked Cookie Co. and order this dessert subscription box on their Crate Joy page here.
Chocolate Maven
Maven Monthly Baked Subscription
So what is Chocolate Maven exactly?
It’s a name of this bakery that originally began 50+ years ago as a small Santa Fe pastry shop. Back then they were known for their brownies, hot chocolate and late night poetry readings.
Since then, they’ve GROWN!
Now they ship their delicious baked goods nationwide and operate a full service restaurant that offers breakfast, brunch and lunch.
You can even see the bakery in action while you’re dining.
That brings us to their monthly dessert subscription, where you’ll get to sample some of the items from Chocolate Maven’s best treats – from their signature pies to ultra gourmet cookies.
Chocolate Maven offers two subscription levels – the essentials box and the deluxe box for an additional $6. To give you a taste, here’s a peek at some of the dessert subscription boxes they’ve got planned!
And if you choose the deluxe upgrade, you’ll receive this in addition to the essentials box!
If you want more detail on each month, see the full description here.
Some highlights include chocolate cherry pies, lemon Piccadilly cookies, mint chocolate brownies, chocolate espresso cookies, ginger snap cookies, triple chocolate bundt cake and more.
BUY: Check out more information about Chocolate Maven and order your own dessert subscription box for delivery on their homepage here.
If ice cream is your thing, Jeni’s offers a 3, 6 or 12 month ice cream subscription called a Pint Club.
Each month you’ll receive a selection of four carefully curated ice cream flavors – usually before they’re available to the public. The first month, you’ll get a welcome letter, a schedule so you know when your next ice cream delivery will be and a set of Jeni’s favorite ice cream spades or ice cream scoop.
If you’re thinking about gifting Jeni’s Pint Club, they’ll help you keep it a surprise by only notifying them that they’ve been gifted a subscription when they actually receive their first box. They won’t get an email before it ships, so it really will be a surprise when it arrives on their doorstep.
Oh and Jeni’s ships A LOT of ice cream, so don’t worry about it arriving melted. They’re ice cream experts and this is what they do for a living.
BUY: Check out more information about Jeni’s Ice Cream and order your own 3,6 or 12 month ice cream dessert subscription on their website here.
Vermont Brownie Company
For gourmet brownie delivery, go to Vermont Brownie Company and check out their monthly brownie programs.
You can choose between a 3, 6 and 12-month subscription and either a half or full dozen brownies. This is a great gift idea and the brownies come in a nice gift box each month. They’ll get that Christmas feeling each time they open it up.
You can add extras like a ribbon to the brownie box or a personalized greeting card and even choose the packaging theme, depending on the occasion you’re buying it for:
- Lots Of Love
- Red Hearts
- Winter Night
- Classic Vermont
- Blue Sky
- Merry & Bright
The brownies come individually wrapped, so you can get your brownie fix anytime and it’ll always be super fresh.
Reviewers love the quality, flavor and freshness, saying frequently that they’re delicious and they arrived moist with awesome flavor.
BUY: Check out more information about Vermont Brownie Company and order your own brownie dessert subscription box on their website here.
Etsy
Ok, so how about amazing fudge delivered to your doorstep each month?
This awesome dessert subscription by Etsy seller Mama And Papaws Closet has a TON of top rated reviews – we’re talking 2,200+ reviews!
You’ll get one pound of delicious homemade fudge each month.
They make all their fudge fresh to order, so you won’t get something that’s been sitting on a shelf for a few weeks. No way! They want you to come back and order more!
Check out some of the fudge flavors offered by this top rated Etsy shop:
- Butterscotch
- Raspberry Cheese Cake
- Maple Walnut
- Cherry Pecan
- Peppermint
- Chocolate
- Tiger Butter
Unfortunately you can’t pick and choose your flavors, but you can view their schedule on their Etsy page and see if it’s something you’d like to receive.
BUY: Check out more information about this Etsy shop and order your fudge subscription box on their Etsy page here.
Cravory Cookies
The Cravory has been serving their gourmet cookies to the people of Point Loma, San Diego since 2014. Now they’re offering their cookies nationwide.
They’re known for new cookie flavors – not the same old thing you see everywhere. They’ve actually sold over 5,000 unique cookie flavors and make it a rule to create six new flavors each and every month.
That’s a TON of flavors!
They’re obsessed with how their cookies taste, their freshness and the experience you get with your very first bite.
Their monthly subscription is offered in three sizes:
- Half a Dozen
- 1 Dozen
- 2 Dozen
And you’ll always find six different, unique flavors in every box.
Reviewers love these cookies, with multiple people commenting how much they loved their cookies, or how much the lucky recipient loved them!
BUY: Check out more information about The Cravory and order your own cookie dessert subscription box on their website here.
Jessie’s Nutty Cups
Want something a bit different? Try out Jessie’s Nutty Cups and her gourmet peanut butter subscription on Crate Joy!
Each month Jessie’s will deliver a variety of handcrafted peanut butter and almond butter cups. You’ll get 6 of their all-time favorite flavors as well as a couple of their special Nutty Cup of the month flavors to keep things interesting.
The treats are all made to order and they guarantee only the freshest peanut butter cups will be included in your next favorite subscription box.
Choose from either an assorted box of 8 or 15 peanut butter cups and a subscription of either 1, 3 or 6 months. You’ll save more per box the longer you decide to subscribe.
Reviewers love what they’re receiving, with some people gifting it to others (and they didn’t share back!).
Other people gifted it to themselves and loved that they not only got tasty treats, but helped support a small business. It’s a fun gift idea – I mean, when did you last get a gift box full of gourmet peanut butter cups??
Now’s your chance!
BUY: Check out more information about Jessie’s Nutty Cups and order your own dessert subscription box for delivery on their Crate Joy page here.
Gold Belly
Monthly Pie Subscription
Ok, so you’ve seen cookies, brownies, ice cream, fudge and peanut butter cups – how about a monthly pie subscription box from gourmet food delivery marketplace Gold Belly?
This is a neat subscription – you’ll get to sample pies from a variety of bakeries across America each month.
You won’t get the same thing – from the same bakery. It’s an excellent way to go on a dessert pie adventure without the hassle of arranging delivery yourself.
And how about a totally unique gift idea!
Once you order, enter the recipient’s email address on the checkout page (along with their home address for delivery) and Gold Belly will email the lucky recipient with your special gift message and an announcement of what they’re about to receive.
Each pie will serve between 8-10 people and you can choose between a 3, 6, 9 or 12 month plan.
If you want an example of some of the pies that have been offered previously, check these out!
- Dangerously Delicious “Baltimore Bomb” Pie
- Brooklyn’s Break Out Salty Honey Pie
- Wisconsin’s Elegant Farmer “Brown Bag” Apple Pie
- Kentucky’s Iconic “Derby” Pie from Kern’s Kitchen
- Texas’ Legendary Royers Pies “Texas Trash Pie”
BUY: Check out more information about this monthly dessert pie subscription and order your own on their Gold Belly page here.
Jackie’s Chocolate
Monthly Chocolate Subscription
Jackie’s Chocolate wants to send you one of their indulgent chocolate variety boxes!
Sign up to this dessert subscription box and you’ll get a handpicked selection of creamy truffles, smooth caramels and fresh crunchy nuts, all enrobed in the finest milk chocolate, dark chocolate or white chocolate.
There’s about 15 chocolates packed into each gift box and they’ll ship them direct to anyone for birthdays, celebrations or just because. The first box ships within 7 days, with the next one shipping every 4 weeks after. Choose from a 1-time box, 3-month, 6-month or 12-month chocolate subscription.
BUY: Check out more information about Jackie’s Chocolates and order your own dessert subscription box on their website here.
Mystery Chocolate
So you love chocolate, but are looking for something a bit out of the box and not the same old stuff you get at the grocery store? Check out this awesome dessert subscription box that supplies you with 3 mystery chocolate bars each month.
Here’s how it works. You’ll get the box home and inside will find 3 chocolate bars, labelled simply as “A”, “B” and “C”.
Open the chocolate bars and try and identify what the ingredients are. The included mystery chocolate bars are carefully selected with unique interesting flavors that are impossible to find locally.
Submit the guesses via the mystery chocolate website and they’ll reveal the actual flavors. Compare and see if you were close!
For every box sold, Mystery Chocolate will donate two meals to charity. One to the United States and another meal for the rest of the world.
This is a different type of dessert subscription that’ll be delicious and fun at the same time. It’s also an amazing gift idea for any chocoholic.
Choose between a 3, 6 or 12 month subscription and Mystery Chocolate will take care of the rest.
BUY: Check out more information about Mystery Chocolate and order your own chocolate bar dessert subscription box on their website here.
Etsy – Gigi’s Table
Maybe you’re shopping for a gift idea for someone who has everything. They’ve got the fancy tech, fancy shoes and a fancy ride.
I bet they don’t have a fancy monthly cookie delivery though?
Now’s your chance to surprise them with this offering from Etsy store Gigi’s Table.
Order this and Gigi’s Table will take care of the rest.
They’ll make, bake, pack and ship gourmet cookies to almost any doorstep in America. You’ll get to choose 3 flavors from a mouth watering list.
Check some of our favorites out:
- Lemon Blueberry Shortbread (18 ea)
- Mexican Wedding Cookies (18 ea)
- Chocolate Espresso Cookies With Espresso Buttercream (12 ea)
- Lemon Wedding Cookies (18 ea)
- Chocolate Cherry Almond Shortbread (18 ea)
- +Many More!
If you are buying this for a gift, just let the Etsy seller know and she’ll add any message you want inside the gift box. She’ll also add a note detailing how long the subscription is for and when they can expect their next shipment.
Reviewers are raving about this Etsy shop and their cookies, with multiple people rating it a straight 5-stars. Choose from a 3 month, 6 month, 9 month or 12 month subscription.
BUY: Check out more information about Etsy shop Gigi’s Table and order your own dessert subscription box on their Etsy page here.
Ten Thousand Cookies
Gluten Free & Vegan Cookie Subscription Box
Here’s a dessert subscription box that’s gluten free and vegan. It’s from a small bakery called Ten Thousand Cookies.
They’ll make, pack and ship 12 of their gourmet cookies straight to your home:
- 2 Chocolate Chip
- 2 Sugar Cookies (with sprinkles)
- 2 Monster Cookies
- 6 Flavor of-the-month
All of the cookies are made with gluten free and vegan ingredients and expertly baked by pastry chefs.
Choose between their “Cookie Crate” or just opt for their “Monster Cookies” for a fun change.
Reviewers say that the cookies are “the best gluten-free cookies I have ever had” and that they “can’t even tell that the sugar cookies are gluten-free.”
This is definitely one to check out if you’re following a specific diet.
BUY: Check out more information about Ten Thousand Cookies and order your own dessert subscription box on their Crate Joy page here.
Color My Cookie
The last dessert subscription box I have to show you today is this creative treat from Color My Cookie.
It’s made by a place called Tart Bakery, and they’re well known for their simple yet delicious treats. Every month you’ll get a box with six pre-iced shortbread cookies.
You’ll also get their signature edible watercolor palette, paint brushes, icing, sprinkles or edible glitter and a link so you can watch a real pastry chef decorate the exact same ones you received to get you started with ideas.
It’s a really neat idea to be able to watch a pro transform these plain cookies into a fun and decorative treat…of course, you can decorate them anyway you want!
It’s a really fun and kids especially have a BLAST decorating their own cookies, just like the professional bakeries do.
The cookies are pre-iced, so you don’t have to worry about mixing up anything and it being too thin or thick.
You can just start thinking about how you’ll decorate your own cookies and who knows, you might come up with something even better than the pros!
Reviewers love being able to decorate the cookies by themselves – and don’t be mistaken, they taste awesome as well. If you have any questions about the cookie kits, you can get answers right from the people that create it fast as they’re available to help whenever you should need it.
Checking out the reviews more – it’s very popular to purchase this kit to make with grandkids and young children. They’ll get to decorate their own cookies and eat them once they’re done!
One reviewer said she was able to “virtually” decorate these cookies with her grandkids in the middle of the COVID lockdown.
BUY: Check out more information about Color My Cookie and order your own dessert subscription box on their Crate-Joy page here.
Summary
You’ve got some great options when it comes to finding the best dessert subscription box for delivery.
If brownies are your go-to treat, check out the Brownie Of The Month club on Etsy. This Etsy shop is run by Revolution 9 Bakery and they have a TON of ratings – over 4,400+.
They’ll deliver a dozen brownies to your doorstep (or another lucky person’s doorstep) and you get to pick the flavor from 16 different varieties.
Another option for a monthly gourmet brownie subscription box is from Vermont Brownie Company. They’re more expensive than Revolution 9, but offer moist, delicious brownies in individual wrappers for freshness. The brownies come in a simple but colorful gift box and they ship anywhere.
Perhaps cookies are more to your liking?
No worries, I have you covered there too. You’ve got a few different options, some of the best being from Cravory Cookies. They somehow have managed to come up with 5,000 unique cookie flavors since they opened in 2014 and offer no less than 6 new flavors each month you subscribe. That means there’ll be always something you love from a classic flavor and always be something you haven’t tried before.
It’s a great way to try out new flavors, but also the safety of knowing the flavors will be awesome.
For a different kind of cookie dessert subscription box, try out Fresh Baked Cookie Co. They’ll send you all the ingredients – in pre-measured bags – for you to make gourmet cookies right in your own home. You will have to add butter – but everything is has been done for you. You’ll get 18-24 premium cookies out of each box and they include 2-3 additional surprises just for fun, like aprons, fun socks and even luxury room fragrances.
Etsy is overflowing with high quality small businesses that make premium treats. One Etsy shop – Gigi’s Table – specializes in cookies and offers a “cookie of the month club”.
Subscribe, and Gigi’s Table will create, pack and ship their cookies almost anywhere. They’ve got an impressive flavor list to choose from, like Chocolate Espresso Cookies (HELLO) and Lemon BlueBerry Shortbread.
Get gluten free and vegan cookies delivered to your door when you subscribe to Ten Thousand Cookies.
They’ll ship 6 of their most popular flavors like chocolate chip and sugar cookies, but also include 6 cookies that feature their flavor of the month.
Maybe you’ve got small kids in your family?
Then look at Color My Cookie. They’ll love being able to decorate their own cookies using the included icing and sprinkles and of course eat it when they’re done!
What makes Color My Cookie special, is that you can see the very same cookies that are delivered to your door being professionally decorated by a real pastry chef. Just scan the QR code with your phone and you’ll be able to watch the video. It’s a pretty neat idea!
For chocolates, you’re spoiled for choice there too. Jackie’s Chocolate offer’s their variety chocolate boxes for delivery every month that includes a mix of truffles, caramels and crunch nut chocolates.
If you want to spice things up a bit and have fun while you eat amazing chocolate, try the Mystery Chocolate subscription box. It’s really unique in that you’ll receive three chocolate bars that are simply labelled A, B and C. Try and guess the ingredients, then check what they really where using the special link that’s included in the box. It’s a fun way to try new chocolates and also a mini game to see who could identify them the best.
Jessie’s Nutty Cups should also be on your list if you can’t get enough chocolate. You’ll get six of their best selling peanut butter cups and a couple of their new flavors for you to try. Sign up to this dessert subscription box for 1, 3 or 6 months.
You can get pretty much anything delivered – so why not check out an ice cream dessert subscription box?
Jeni’s Ice Cream offers it’s Ice Cream Pint Club from $63/mo. You’ll get four select ice cream flavors and you can try them before they’re offered to the general public. Sign up to a 3, 6 or 12 month plan and enjoy savings for the longer you subscribe.
Get a fudge dessert subscription box on Etsy from the Homemade Fudge Of The Month Club. This Etsy store is super highly rated – with 2,000+ reviews and counting. You’ll get a pound of fudge each and every month and they’re all made fresh to order. You can’t choose the flavors unfortunately, but they’ve got a good rotation and feature yummy creations like cherry pecan, raspberry cheesecake and butterscotch.
For something a bit more substantial, you can buy a monthly pie subscription box from Gold Belly. It’s pretty unique because you’ll be receiving gourmet dessert pies from bakeries all across the country. Previous pies were delivered from bakeries in Baltimore, Kentucky, Brooklyn and Texas to name a few. The pies are a decent size, feeding 8-10 people. Or me, once.
I really liked the idea of Phivi Artisanal Desserts – a monthly dessert subscription box that features a wide range of treats. From cakes to brownies, cookies, macarons, cake pops and more. There are 8 full-sized desserts in each box and it’s always a surprise to see what treats are new each month. Their Crate Joy page has over 100+ ratings and almost a straight 5-star score.
Chocolate Maven is another really interesting dessert subscription box. Out of New Mexico, you can choose an Essentials Box or upgrade to their Deluxe Box. You’ll receive all sorts of gourmet desserts like pies, bars, cakes, loafs and more. You can see what desserts are planned to be shipped in their subscription boxes on their website and see if it looks like something you wouldn’t mind trying….pretty much everything is worth trying!
Whichever dessert subscription box you decide to choose, you’ve got an amazing selection and the most difficult part is to decide which one you’ll start with first.
If you liked this article, check out these delicious reads!
