Try new roasts picked out by expert coffee masters in this top list of Keurig K-Club Coffee Subscription Clubs.
- Best Overall Keurig K-Cup coffee subscription club at Keurig | $11.99+
- Top rated build your own Keurig K-Cup Subscription Box At Peet’s Coffee | $16.95+
- Best mix of everything – regular, flavored and decaf – at Mixed Single Cup Club | $9.92+
- Mystery K-Cup coffee subscription club selection at MixCups or Coffee Cargo | $19/$14.99
- Most value for money 60ct variety K-Cup box at Amazon
Every one of the recommendations below are compatible with machines that use the K-Cup pods. You won’t see bags of coffee beans or Nespresso pods stuff here…this is 100% Keurig K-Cup only.
Here are your top choices for the best Keurig K-Cup coffee subscription clubs.
Keurig
Coffee from the maker!
K-Cup Coffee Subscription
So instead of saying subscription, Keurig calls it auto-delivery. It’s the same thing, almost.
Keurig offers a service where you can pick your favorite k-cup pods (or ones that could be your next favorite) and they’ll deliver them month after month.
There’s not much surprise in it, but if you’re like me and know what you like and don’t need to explore (and shudder at the thought of change), this auto-delivery service could be right for you.
You’ll save 25% on each auto-delivery, and you’ll be getting k-cups straight from the company that made your Keurig, so they’ll be good quality and compatible (i.e. they work and you won’t end up getting coffee ground bits in your mug. Yuk).
I thought you should see Keurig’s own auto-delivery/subscription service first because it’s the safest exploration out of this list. You’ll get to pick and choose K-Cup flavors that look good to you. There’s still an element of surprise because you haven’t tried them, but it’s most likely to be enjoyed.
You can see recommendations by Keurig depending on your preference in roast or flavor along with reviews to help you pick out new roasts that look good. A click/tap on Dark Roast brought up three brands (Dunkin, Green Mountain, Panera Bread), each with high reviews.
Keurig also shows collections that are available to buy – things like Flavor Variety Best Sellers or Cafe Style Beverages.
If you want the full mystery of not knowing what you’ll receive (aside from it being coffee), check out the other recommendations below.
Shipping is free on orders over $29+.
BUY: Check out more information on Keurig and setup your own auto-delivery schedule on their website here.
Peet’s Coffee
Great dark roast coffee!
Build Your Own Subscription
Peets Coffee offers a build-your-own subscription box where you can select from 17 gourmet K-Cup coffee types that ship for free every month.
Other perks of a Peet’s Coffee subscription are discounts. You’ll enjoy:
- 5% off $30
- 10% off $50
New subscribers get a free Peet’s Coffee pin set as a bonus, too:
You have to options – pick your favorites from their catalog of coffees or take Peet’s coffee quiz and they’ll identify potential matches that you should try.
There’s no harm in taking the quiz and not purchasing anything that’s recommended, but it will help you get coffee home that you’re more likely to enjoy. It’s only 5 questions..
BUY: Check out more information on Peet’s Coffee and subscribe to a build-your-own K-Cup box on their website here.
Coffee Club
Mystery is exciting!
K-Cup Subscripton
If you want to add some mystery and excitement to your coffee subscription, Coffee Club will choose 3-5 different varieties and ship them fresh to any doorstep every month.
This is a great way to try new coffees, without having to purchase an entire box just for a sample.
Never have a boring cup of coffee again!
You can choose between a 3 or 6-month subscription in these configurations:
- Coffee Sampler Pack (just coffee)
- Variety Sampler Pack (flavored coffees)
BUY: Check out more information on Coffee Club and subscribe to your own Keurig K-Cup coffee sampler on their website here.
Cross Country Cafe
Experienced coffee subscription company
K-Cup Dark Roast or Flavored Subscription
Cross Country Cafe has been in the coffee distrubution business for decades and their family run company offers two different types of subscriptions Keurig K-Cup pods.
- Dark Roast K-Cup Coffee Of The Month
- Flavored K-Cup Coffee Of The Month
- Regular Roast K-Cup Coffee Of The Month
Dark Roast
Their Dark Roast K-Cup Coffee of The Month subscription supplies 48 of the darkest roast gourmet coffees available. Brands include Green Mountain Dark Magic and Starbucks French Roast. It’s priced at $48/mo.
Flavored Roast
For variety, try their Flavored K-Cup Coffee Of The Month subscription. Included are 48 k-cups, in two flavors like hazelnut and vanilla or new blends like wild mountain blueberry and of course pumpkin spice!
Regular Roast
Finally Cross Country Cafe offers a Regular Roast K-Cup subscription club for light to medium roast coffee lovers. Again, there’s 48 cups in two packs of 24 with roasts from Green Mountain and Starbucks.
A heads up, you get two boxes of 24 k-cups – so if you don’t like one flavor….there’ll be a lot of unused K-Cups to deal with. Four boxes of 12 with four flavors would have been preferred by more I think.
BUY: Check out more information on Cross Country Cafe and subscribe to your own K-Cup subscription on their website here. All coffee subscription clubs are $28.50.
Amazon
Variety Packs
Various Keurig K-Cup Subscription Options
So you’re seeing Amazon on this list because it is a good place to look for new fun Keurig K-Cups in a variety of roasts and flavors.
For an instant gourmet coffee collection that brings home 60 K-Cup pods, get the Keurig Coffee Lover’s Collection that’s on free Prime shipping.
Go BIG and get this 100-count Keurig K-Cup coffee variety pack with 10 different flavors to choose from!
If you find a variety pack that you like, you can subscribe and save money on future deliveries.
There are more coffee samplers and variety packs to see on Amazon, check them all out here.
Mixcups
A mystery coffee subscription that’s catered to your tastes
K-Cup Subscription
Mixcups are dedicated to single serve Keurig K-Cups. You can choose from three sizes and three roast/flavor plans:
- Mini Mix (15 Keurig K-Cups / Month)
- Medium Mix (45 Keurig K-Cups / Month)
- Mega Mix (90 Keurig K-Cups / Month)
Next, you’ll get to choose how you like your coffee – regular or flavored. If you want to try both, they also have a plan for that called the Non Flavored Mix.
- Ultimate Mix (Half Flavored, Half Non Flavored)
- Standard Mix (All Flavored)
- Non Flavor Mix (All regular coffee without flavoring)
Lastly, chose the length of your subscription:
- Month to month ($18.95+)
- 3 Month prepay ($17.95+)
- 6 Month prepay ($16.95+)
- 12 Month prepay ($15.95+)
Aside from choosing flavored or non, that’s all the input you’ll need for them to curate a coffee sampling box for you. This is really a good option for mystery as they try and add as many different coffees into the selection you choose as possible.
Their least expensive box for non-flavor coffee varieties, delivers 10 different types of coffee with a few duplicates of MixCups most favorite roast for a total of 15 cups. It’s $18.95 a month and goes down the longer you subscribe.
BUY: Check out more information on MixCups and subscribe to one of their gourmet Keurig K-Cup coffee club subscriptions on their website here.
Mixed Single Cup Club
From Cratejoy
Single Cup Club
Over 100 people have left an average rating of 4.2/5 on subscription box marketplace CrateJoy.
Amongst the many different subscriptions is Single Cup Club, who delivers small batch roasted coffees in the conveniences of a Keurig K-Cup each month.
They deliver three different blends of coffee and you’ll get five K-Cups of each blend. Also included are detailed descriptions of the coffees and the roaster.
The varieties included are pretty much everything – light, medium and dark and flavored and there’s no way to opt out of something. A deal breaker for some and why this isn’t at the number one spot.
Having said that, they are well recieved and people are liking what they’ve been given by Mixed Single Cup Club Membership.
BUY: Check out more information about Single Cup Club and their Mixed Single Cup Club Membership on their CrateJoy page here.
Tayst
Insanely great coffee
Keurig K-Cup Coffee Subscription
Tayst does it a little differently and only offers it’s own roasted coffee blends for inclusion into their monthly coffee subscription clubs. On the other hand, one awesome side to Tayst roasting and blending their own coffees is that they can supply as many (or few) pods of each flavor that you want. One K-Cup of each flavor? You’ve got it.
….But they’ve only got 7 varieties to choose from right now..
Their most affordable plan – 30 Keurig K-Cups at $22/month – you can choose from these blends:
- Bold & Brazen
- Bold & Brilliant
- Medium & Heroic
- Medium & Magnificent
- Vintage Vanilla
- Defiantly Decaf
- Happy Hazelnut
Their pricing is by how many K-Cups you think you’ll need. The minimum is 30 at $22/month.
BUY: Check out more information on Tayst and order your own monthly Keurig K-Cup subscription on their website here.
Coffee Cargo
Good price, limited choices
Keurig K-Cup Subscription
Coffee Cargo has a simple approach to it’s Keurig K-Cup coffee subscription club. They offer one box size, with 3 different roasts and 15 K-Cups total.
The only decision you have to make is how long of a subscription you’d like to buy:
A perk of Coffee Cargo is that their shipping is free no matter what subscription length you choose.
Coffee Cargo chooses to use Keurig K-Cups because they’re a really easy and accessible way to try different coffees without having to break your normal daily routine. The K-Cup pods also help to keep the coffee in the best condition possible as they’re air and water tight so you’ll get a really fresh brew.
BUY: Check out more information on Coffee Cargo and subscribe to it’s Keurig K-Cup subscription club on their website here.
Roundup
You’ve got some awesome options if you’re looking for the best Keurig K-Cup coffee subscription clubs online.
It really comes down to what you’re looking for – something a bit different, but is still in your comfort zone, or would you prefer to receive a mystery selection of Keurig K-Cup coffees where you’ll only find out what you get…when you get them!
For the best…and safest…Keurig K-Cup coffee club subscription, try Peet’s Coffee, Keurig themselves or Tayst. Here you’ll be able to pick out the type of coffee you’ll receive and specify if you prefer flavored, non flavored or a mix. It would be a huge bummer to get a box of coffee home and it’s just not drinkable because it’s all flavored. Unless that’s your thing…
For a mystery selection, Coffee Cargo with their free shipping or MixCups with their three different mixes (standards, flavored, or combo).
Here you’ll be selecting a quantity of Keurig K-Cups and maybe only if the selections sent to you should be flavored or not. The rest, is up to the roasters and what they hand pick to include in your special coffee subscription box.
Finally, Amazon is always worth a look. They have some huge variety packs like their 60 count that’s priced affordably and shipped fast with Prime.
