You can find a great selection of ice cream cakes online – ready to be delivered straight to your door.
There’s a wide selection – from ultra gourmet ice cream cakes to more budget friendly ice cream cakes – there’s sure to be one that will fit your event or occasion perfectly.
- Best customizable ice cream cake @ Bartleby’s | $55
- Peppermint ice cream cake @ Sugar Hill Creamery | $79
- Locally sourced honey ice cream cake @ Revival Ice Cream | $67
- Mint Chocolate ice cream cake @ Anderson’s Frozen Custard | $125
- Most WOW ice cream cake @ Life Raft Treats | $109
- Most Exotic ice cream cake @ Noona’s Ice Cream | $69
- Fastest shipping ice cream cakes @ Morgenstern’s | $119
In this roundup, you’ll see creameries like Bartleby’s offering custom made ice cream cakes for delivery, but you’ll also discover gourmet ice cream shops with signature cakes – like Revival Ice Cream and their locally sourced honey and beeswax ice cream cake.
Let’s check out the top places online that deliver ice cream cakes nationwide!
Sugar Hill Creamery
#1 Peppermint Ice Cream Cake
This is a superb looking ice cream cake from gourmet ice cream shop Sugar Hill Creamery.

They’ve made their peppermint bark ice cream cake with real ingredients and no artificial peppermint flavorings.
The base of this cake is chocolate graham cracker and filled with creamy vanilla bean ice cream.
It’s topped with a rich chocolate glaze and finished with a sprinkle of white chocolate and peppermint candy cane.

BUY: Check out more information about Sugar Hill Creamery and order your own peppermint bark ice cream cake on their Gold Belly page here.
Revival Ice Cream
Custom Ice Cream Cake
Make Your Own 9″ Ice Cream Cake
Revival Ice Cream was founded in Monterey, California back in 2016 and have made themselves somewhat of a local hotspot for gourmet ice cream treats.

Their make your own 9-inch ice cream cake is popular – allowing you to choose the top and bottom layer ice cream flavors, sponge cake flavor and even the topping.

This is an awesome customizable ice cream cake we found online that can be delivered nationwide.
Choose from these ice cream flavors:
- Bees Knee’s (Locally sourced honey ice cream)
- Banana Caramel
- Dark Chocolate
- Milk and Cookies
- Mint Eucalyptus Chocolate Chip
- Vanilla
- Apple Pie
- Coffee
- Kid’s Cookie Dough
- Nuts & Fluff
- Lemon Peel Sherbet
- Salted Caramel
- Bee’s Knees (vegan)
- Summer Lemonade (vegan)
- Passionfruit Mango (vegan)
- Chocolate Hazelnut (vegan)
- Peanut Butter Chip (vegan)
Choose between chocolate or vanilla sponge cake and a topping:
- Chocolate Soil (chocolate crumbs/bits)
- Vanilla Soil (vanilla crumbs/bits)
- Toasted Marshmallow
- Honeycomb Candy
- Hazelnut Crunch
Revival Ice Cream can turn an order around in 72 hours (3 days), pretty good for a custom cake.

BUY: Check out more information about Revival Ice Cream and order your ice cream cake for delivery on their website here.
Anderson’s Frozen Custard
Chocolate Mint Overload
If you’re looking for a show stopper – an ice cream cake that they’ll be talking about long after your event or celebration is over – this is it.
Anderson’s mint fudge ganache ice cream cake is hand made – piece by piece – and sets the standard for luxury ice cream cakes.

This cake features hand made gourmet chocolate-mint ice cream that sandwiches a heavenly layer of chocolate fudge and cookie crunch in the middle.
On top, the cake has Anderson’s hand made chocolate chunk ice cream and it’s enrobed in a rich chocolate ganache.
The ice cream cake is finished with mint cream rosettes and individual Andes Mints.
This is a medium-large ice cream cake. It’ll serve 8-12 people and measures 8″ across and 3.5″ in height.
I wish there were more photos of this epic ice cream cake to show you. Maybe I’ll reach out to Anderson’s for a sample cake, for research.
BUY: Check out more information about Anderson’s and order your own mint fudge ganache ice cream cake on their Gold Belly page here.
Morgenstern’s
Gourmet ice cream flavor combinations
Ice Cream Cakes (Various Flavors)
Choose from six gourmet ice cream cakes – all of which an be shipped nationwide directly from gourmet ice creamery Morgenstern’s.

The ice cream at Morgenstern’s is made in small batches for maximum quality. You can choose between six delicious ice cream cake flavors:
- Strawberry Vanilla Ice Cream Cake – Two types of ice cream, “Smooth & Delicious Strawberry” and “Madagascar Vanilla Ice Cream” with vanilla sponge cake, strawberry jam and vanilla whipped cream.
- Cookies ‘n’ Cream Ice Cream Cake – Vanilla cake, Oreo cookies, Cookies ‘n’ cream whipped cream frosting
- Chocolate Ice Cream Cake – Chocolate ice cream on chocolate sponge cake, chocolate whipped cream (gluten free)
- Burnt Honey Vanilla Ice Cream Cake – Burnt honey vanilla ice cream on honey sponge cake, honey vanilla crumble, honeycomb, honey drizzle and honey whipped cream.
- Schoolyard Mint Chip Ice Cream Cake – Edible schoolyard mint chip ice cream on chocolate sponge cake with dark chocolate chunks, mint whipped cream frosting. Gluten Free
- Salted Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream Cake – Salted caramel pretzel ice cream on caramel sponge cake, caramel whipped cream and pretzels





All of the ice cream cakes and frozen treats at Morgenstern’s ship next day UPS Air to make sure you receive the ice cream cake still frozen fresh.
BUY: Check out more information about Morgenstern’s and order your own ice cream cake for delivery on their website here.
Bartleby’s
Best custom ice cream cakes
Ice cream cake specialists Bartleby’s offer’s it’s gourmet treats for nationwide delivery.
You can order a custom ice cream cake that includes:
- Two layers of ice cream (you pick)
- Two layers of crumbles (you pick)
- Whipped cream frosting (you pick)
- Up to 3 decorations (you pick)

For the ice cream flavors, choose your two favorites from these options:
- Chocolate
- Vegan Chocolate
- Coffee
- Vegan Coffee
- Cookie Dough
- Vegan Cookie Dough
- Cookies and Cream
- Vegan Cookies and Cream
- Vegan Ginger Rum (seasonal special)
- Salted Caramel
- Strawberry
- Vegan Strawberry
- Sugar Cone Crunch
- Vegan Sugar Cone Crunch
- Toasted Coconut
- Vegan Toasted Coconut
- Vanilla
- Vegan Vanilla

For the crumble topping, choose one of these options:
- Blondies
- Brownies
- Vegan Chocolate Cake
- Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Gluten Free Chocolate Cookies
- Oatmeal Cookies
- Vegan Oatmeal Cookies
For example, if you choose brownies, they’ll crumble up brownie pieces on top of the cake.
The whipped cream options sound delish:
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Coconut Cream
- Chocolate Coconut Cream
Not only can you choose the message on top of the ice cream cake, but you can choose the ingredients used to write your message:
- Caramel
- Coconut Cream (Vegan)
- Fudge
Finally, choose the decorations you’d like on the cake – maximum of two:
- Caramel Sauce
- Chocolate Chip cookie Dough (Vegan)
- Chocolate Sprinkles (Vegan)
- Chopped Sandwich Cookies (Vegan)
- Fudge Sauce
- Mini Chocolate Chips (Vegan)
- Mini Cones (Vegan)
- Nuts (Almonds, Pecans or Pistachios)
- Rainbow Sprinkles (Vegan)
- Toasted Coconut Flakes

Bartleby’s also offers the option to include a card or candle with your custom ice cream cake – a nice touch to really deliver a celebration to someone’s home, even if you can’t be there to personally share it with them.
BUY: Check out more information about Bartleby’s and order your own custom ice cream cake for delivery on their website here.
Life Raft Treats
OMG! DELICIOUS.
Candied Apple Butterscotch Crumble Ice Cream Cake
To make this epic ice cream cake, Life Raft Treats hunts for the most juiciest and crisp apples they can find, then candy them for a delectable infusion of sweetness.

You can’t miss the thick layers of rich butterscotch ice cream that sandwich the moist cinnamon butter sponge cake.

On top is another layer of butterscotch ice cream and a handful of their crunchy vanilla crumble for a finishing touch.

BUY: Check out more information about Life Raft Treats and buy your own mail order ice cream cake on their Gold Belly page here.
Noona’s Ice Cream
Asian influence
At Noona’s Ice Cream, they try to add a little Asian influence in their creations. They’ve been awarded best flavor for their Toasted Rice ice cream at an NYC annual ice cream contest too.

You can have Noona’s Ice Cream make you a customized ice cream cake so it has nothing but your favorite flavors (or their favorite flavor if you’re gifting it).
Noona’s offers their custom cakes in some really unique flavors:
- Matcha Green Tea (with green tea leaves imported from Japan)
- Golden Sesame (toasted sesame seeds with sesame-infused sweet cream)
- Yuzu Blossom (tart and aromatic, citrus)
- Toasted Rice (tastes like rice pudding and waffles)
- Black Sesame (Noona’s favorite: Nutty, bitter with undertones of chocolate).
You can also choose the sponge cake flavor:
- Vanilla Cake
- Toasted Rice Cake
- Black Sesame Cake
- Banana Cake
And finally the crumble layer flavor:
- Chocolate-Black Sesame Cookie Crumble
- Vanilla Cookie Crumble
- Honeycomb Center
- No crumble (extra ice cream added instead)

Noona’s is also open to custom requests – even going as far as customizing the whipped cream flavor and occasion/event decoration.
It’s perfect if you’re shopping for a celebration cake.
BUY: Check out more information about Noona’s and order your own ice cream cake for delivery on their website here.
Summary
You’ve got some great options when it comes to shopping for an ice cream cake for delivery. All of the options above will ship an ice cream cake to your door, and a lot of them offer a completely customized cake.
Sugar Hill Creamery offers a luxury peppermint bark ice cream cake and used their rich creamy vanilla bean ice cream, chocolate glaze and real peppermint candy cane bits.
The base is bold chocolate graham cracker that balances the creamy vanilla bean ice cream perfectly.
It’s not the largest ice cream cake for delivery on this list, at 6-inches across. Sugar Hill Creamery says it’ll serve 8-10 people but I’m not sure about that!
Revival Ice Cream offers a make your own 9-inch cake, where you can choose the top and bottom ice cream flavors, the sponge cake flavors and the topping flavor.
One flavor that stands out is their signature award winning Bee’s Knee’s ice cream.
They use locally sourced Monterey honey and beeswax for a completely organic flavor you won’t be able to get enough of.
Folded into the honey infused ice cream are crunchy pieces of their homemade honeycomb candy.
I can’t imagine a cake being made with this ice cream!
If you want to blow everyone away – including your own eyes when you open the shipping box – check out the mint fudge ganache ice cream cake from Anderson’s Frozen Custard.
It’s beautiful!
Thick layers of chocolate mint and chocolate chunk ice cream sandwich a tunnel of chocolate fudge and cookie crunch in the middle. It’s covered in a generous layer of rich chocolate ganache and decorated with real Andes mints.
There’s no hiding – it’s one of the more expensive ice cream cakes you can get delivered online – but really, to make this cake on your own with the same quality ingredients wouldn’t be easy. It’s perfect for splurging on.
Morgenstern’s offers six flavors of ice cream cakes for delivery. They’re all solid options – but their honey vanilla ice cream cake is definitely worth a look. It features burnt honey vanilla ice cream that’s layered on top of a honey sponge cake. Everything else is honey-infused, from the crumble topping, honey drizzle and even honey whipped cream.
For the most customizable mail order ice cream cake, you need to check out Bartleby’s. Their pricing is fair – at $55. You get a lot of options to choose from:
- Ice cream flavor
- Crumble flavor
- Message flavor
- Whipped cream flavor
- Decorations
They’ve got plenty of ice cream flavors to choose from and are a good place to go when you need a completely custom cake from top to bottom.
For an ice cream cake that can be delivered to your door and will WOW your guests see Life Raft Treats.
They offer a candied apple butterscotch crumble ice cream cake that’s made from the best of the best ingredients.
It’s not your typical ice cream cake where vanilla and chocolate take the spotlight.
This ice cream cake’s hero are the fresh, juicy tart candied apples. Add this to the homemade rich butterscotch ice cream for an unmatched flavor.
The most exotic mail order ice cream cakes we found were at Noona’s ice cream. Their Asian influenced ice cream cakes are filled with unique and different flavors and even have an award under their belt for their “Toasted Rice” flavor ice cream – reminiscent of rice budding and waffle cones.
You can try this flavor or any of their other five flavors in a custom ice cream cake. If you want, you can go over the top with their toasted rice flavor and get a toasted rice sponge cake, with toasted rice ice cream.
Some of the other flavors are really unique and not found anywhere else online for delivery – Yuzu Blossom and Black Sesame ice cream cakes especially.
Hopefully this roundup of the best ice cream cakes for delivery online has helped you choose. There’s a good selection of ice cream cakes available and a surprising amount of customizable ice cream cakes for delivery.
The price ranges from $55 – $125, with our pick for the best customizable ice cream cake for delivery being with Bartleby’s.